1978. 102: Their model shows that worker owned firms can achieve the Pareto optimal level of equilibrium unemployment since, when the owners of the firm coincide with its workers, equilibrium unemployment is lower and Endogenous Effort When Unemployment is a Worker Discipline Device∗ Marco Guerrazzi† Department of Economics University of Pisa (This Version: September 2005) Abstract This paper provides a simple equilibrium dynamic model in which employment evolves according to the rules of the Shapiro-Stiglitz's (1984) shirking model. Labor Contracts as Partial Gift Exchange. 74, No. The presence of such unemploy- ment raises the question of why wages do not fall to clear labor markets. AUTHORS: Michele Alessandrini, Marcello Messori ; and (ii) deriving normative prescriptions for macroeconomic policymaking, in particular regarding the proper setting of fiscal and monetary policies. The efficiency wage idea was first proposed by (Shapiro and Stiglitz 1984) in a paper called Equilbrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device. Research Feed. | 1981 . The presence of such unemploy- ment raises the question of why wages do not fall to clear labor markets. Show all authors. C Shapiro, JE Stiglitz. Shapiro, C., Stiglitz, J. E. "Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device" American Economic Review 74:3 (1984): 433−444. Since dismissal must bite in order to serve as Keyphrases Corrections. 74, issue 3, 433-44 Journal of Business Economics and Management, 7(4), 223-233. I show that, depending on the firms' abilities to assess workers' performance, the discipline device role of unemployment may account for sharp declines in employment and jobless recoveries driven by exceptional increases in the work effort of employees. Carl Shapiro;Joseph E . 9 - Ergonomics. 6621 London: CEPR (December) Sakharov, Andrei (1975), My country and the world, London: Collins and Harvill. In Shapiro and Stiglitz (1984) unemployment is a worker discipline device across homogeneously behaving firms by yielding a strictly positive expected cost of job loss. Downloadable! • Unemployment creates its own penalty for shirking ("unemployment as a worker discipline device"). We draw the following conclusions: (1) Equilibrium unemployment can be at least partly interpreted as a negative external effect of labour contract failures and bilateral opportunism. Shapiro, C. and Stiglitz, J.E. , Carl, and Joseph E. Stiglitz (1984) 'Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device,' American Economic Review 74, 433-44 Shimer, Robert (2005) 'The cyclical behavior of equilibrium . This is short-term unemployment that occurs when people are in between jobs, or they have left education and are waiting to take up their first job. Sileika, A., & Andriusaitiene, D. (2006). * Shapiro, C. and J. Stiglitz, "Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device", AER 1984, 74, 259-293 . 75, issue 4, 892-93 Google Scholar: Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device. Equilibrium is (Qo, Wo) where Qo is the equilibrium amount of labour and Wo is the equilibrium wage. It is shown that, if the full exploitation of tournaments is feasible, there will be no involuntary unemployment. Gertler and Trigari, Unemployment Fluctuations with Staggered Nash Wage Bargaining, JPE, 2009 *Kaplan and Menzio, Shopping Externalities and Self-Fulfilling Unemployment Fluctuations, JPE, 2016. In the 3rd edition of the ILO. Because there is a real cost to losing one's job and entering the pool of unemployed workers, individuals have an incentive to work 15 Consider therefore the first question posed at the outset of this paper. . Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device. Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device By CARL SHAPIRO AND JOSEPH E. STIGLITZ* Involuntary unemployment appears to be a persistent feature of many modem labor markets. Problems of identifying and regulating the structure of the labour market in depressive Lithuanian regions. In the efficiency wage model, unemployment is a worker discipline device [Shapiro and Stiglitz 1984]. 1887 Citations. Philosophy of . Shapiro, C. and Stiglitz, J.E. Schlicht, E. "Labour turnover, wage structure, and natural unemployment" Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics 134 (1978): 337−346. The model also explains why rigid real wages may prevail in equilibrium: the large . A note on the generalisation of the Shapiro-Stiglitz shirking model of involuntary unemployment. The rates of unemployment depend from three factors: economic activity rate, population of people in productive age and the size of employment. equilibrium. Contract employment as a worker discipline device. Higher unemployment makes losing the job more costly, hence encourages workers not to shirk. American Economic Review, 1984, vol. Other Macro Labor Models *Shapiro and Stiglitz, Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device, AER, 1984. With unemployment, even if all firms pay the same wage, a worker has an incentive not to shirk. Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device. By William Maloney. The presence of such unemploy- ment raises the question of why wages do not fall to clear labor markets. This happens because more productive workers -- within any group of individuals with a given set of observable characteristics -- are more willing to accept the risk of being . 99 . What happens if the Discrimination in an equilibrium search model. View Notes - mac03_Labour Market & Unemployment(1) from MICROECONO EC40009 at University of Dundee. The presence of such unemployment raises the question of why wages do not fall to clear labor markets. Save. Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device. In Caballero and Hammour's model, shirking does not arise, but search capital must be positive in equilibrium in order to tilt the payoffs from the employment relationship in favor of the employer sufficiently to induce in- . By Neal Hooker. Tournaments as a Worker Discipline Device Tournaments as a Worker Discipline Device Lin, Chung‐Cheng; Yang, C. C. 2001-10-01 00:00:00 This article explores the macroeconomic implications of tournaments as a worker discipline device in the vein of shirking models. Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device: Reply Carl Shapiro ( ) and Joseph Stiglitz American Economic Review , 1985, vol. David A. Spencer (2002) "Shirking the Issue? In the most widely analyzed type of efficiency wage model of involuntary unemployment, firms pay wages in excess of market clearing to give workers an incentive not to shirk. Such payments in excess of market clearing and the resultant equilibrium unemployment act as a worker discipline device. Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device By CARL SHAPIRO AND JOSEPH E. STIGLITZ* Involuntary unemployment appears to be a persistent feature of many modem labor markets. If firms had perfect information about shirkers so q = , then equilibrium occurs at full employment, where Ld = Ls With monitoring costs, equilibrium occurs where Ld = NSC and unemployment is the gap L NL Title of paper: "Unemployment as a worker discipline device" "Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device." American Economic Review 74 (1984): 433-444. We agree that our 1984 paper was very interesting. "Equilibrium Unemployment and a Worker Discipline Device." The American Economic Review 74 (3): . Quitting and labor turnover : microeconomic evidence and macroeconomic consequences. (1984) Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device. Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device. The American Economic Review, 74, 433-444. has been cited by the following article: TITLE: Workers' Effort: A Comparison between Capitalist and Cooperative Firms. Job Queues and Layoffs in Labor Markets with Flexible Wages. Joseph Stiglitz (S-S, 1984, model hereafter) on unemployment as a worker discipline device. 3.4.1. Phillips, A W (1958), "The relation between unemployment and the rate of change of money wage rates in the UK, 1861-1957", Economica, 25, 100, DOI: 10.2307/2550759. Carl Shapiro and Joseph Stiglitz. Related works & more. equilibrium unemployment. Alert. 45: Involuntary Unemployment as a PrincipalAgent Equilibrium. CiteSeerX - Document Details (Isaac Councill, Lee Giles, Pradeep Teregowda): In their recent article "Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device, " Carl Shapiro and Joseph Stiglitz (1984) have analyzed what happens in a labor maket if firms use dismissal as a sanction for workers detected shirking. According to the conventional wisdom that the result of w implies that workers are exploited by the firm, this finding indicates that the firm does not exploit its employees (w=MRP) when there are involuntary unemployed workers queuing for jobs, but paradoxically exploits workers (w) when there are no workers queuing for jobs. The American Economic Review 74 (3), 433-444. , 1984. (summary) The paper aims to show how the information structure of employer-employee relationships , in particular the inability of employers to costlessly observe workers on the job effort can explain involuntary employment as an equilibrium phenomenon. Hierarchy, Ability, and Income Distribution . 433-444. By Marco Guerrazzi. "The Reasons for Wage Rigidity: Evidence from a Survey of Firms." . Firms have an incentive to pay an efficiency wage that yields an unemployment rate above equilibrium. 1985 Articles Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device: Reply Stiglitz, Joseph E.; Shapiro, Carl Stiglitz and Shapiro tackle equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device. Shapiro, Carl and Joseph Stiglitz (1984), "Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device", American Economic Review, 74 (3), 433-444. In this paper we show how the information structure of em- Worker Discipline Device . "An Equilibrium Model of Imbalances and Low Interest Rates." The Amercial Economic Review 98 (1): 358-93. . •Shapiro, C and J E Stiglitz (1984), "Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device", The American Economic Review 74(3), 433-444. housing unemployment 433 - 444. 66: A Model of the Natural Rate of Unemployment. Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device. • Unemployment creates its own penalty for shirking ("unemployment as a worker discipline device"). 7187. 1984. Working Papers Journal Articles Books and Chapters Software Components. By Carl Shapiro and Joseph Stiglitz; Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device : EconPapers Home About EconPapers. For if he is fired, he will not immediately obtain a new job. Chart also draws from the interpretation in Brian Snowdon and Howard Vane (2005) Modern Macroeconomics. Now in this light, let us revisit the implicit assumption that a -rm always -res a worker who is caught shirking. THE AMERICAN ECONOMIC REVIEW. * Phelps, E., "Consumer Demand and Equilibrium Unemployment in a Working Model of Customer-Market Incentive-Wage Economy ", QJE August 1992, 107-3, 1003-1033 433-444 Subjects Economics Files 4502133.pdf application/pdf 166 KB Also Published In Title American Economic Review More About This Work Academic Units Economics The efficiency wage idea was first proposed by (Shapiro and Stiglitz 1984) in a paper called Equilbrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device.. DOI: 10.1080/17530350. Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device. Journal of Labor Economics 13(2): 309-33. . In this paper, we study a model that incorporates costly job search into an efficiency wage model. Diamond, P. "Aggregate Demand Management in Search Equilibrium." Journal of Political Economy 90 (1982): . If severance pay or work effort (or effective work hours) . All the people who want to work at the wage of Wo, get jobs and are employed. Campbell, C.M., and K.S. Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device Involuntary unemployment appears to be a persistent feature of many modem labor markets. The model for the supply side of the economy is also based on monopolistic-competition where firms have market power to set prices. Download. AUTHORS: Michele Alessandrini, Marcello Messori The intersection of the wage polarization PP schedule and the employment equilibrium EE schedule gives the steady state equilibrium of this model. Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device C. Shapiro, J. Stiglitz Published 1984 Economics The American Economic Review Involuntary unemployment appears to be a persistent feature of many modern labor markets. His work in the fields of Perfect information, Monopoly and Competitive equilibrium overlaps with other areas such as Imperfect. • Monitoring, unemployment and wages are substitutes. Unemployment Equilibria and Input Prices: Theory and Evidence from the United States. unemployment in equilibrium. Informational structure of employer-employee relationship - imperfect monitoring of workers effort on the job Principal-agent problem Higher wages and a pool of unemployment offer incentives for the workers to exert effort This is a central idea of the Shapiro-Stiglitz model (Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device, American . English: Efficiency wage chart based on Sharpiro and Stiglitz (1984) "[Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device" in the American Economic Review. This approach to labor market equilibrium and unemployment has been successful in explaining the determinants of the "natural" rate of unemployment and new data on job and worker flows, in modeling the labor market in equilibrium business cycle and growth models, and in analyzing welfare policy. Equilibrium Unemployment As A Worker Discipline Device Pdf Converter Chapter 2. American Economic Review 74(3): 433-44. We present a model of the labor market with asymmetric information in which the equilibrium of the' market generates unemployment and job queues so that wages may serve as an effective screening device. Kamlani. American Economic Association Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device Author(s): Carl Shapiro and Joseph E. Stiglitz Source: The American Economic Review, Vol. Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device. In this paper we show how the information structure of employer-employee relationships, in particular the inability of employers to costlessly observe workers' on-the-job effort, can explain involuntary unemployment as an equilibrium phenomenon. Their model shows that worker owned firms can achieve the Pareto optimal level of equilibrium unemployment since, when the owners of the firm coincide with its workers, equilibrium unemployment is lower and With unemployment, even if all firms pay the same wage, a worker has an incentive not to shirk. 1 INTRODUCTION We often observe that labor contracts specify rigid wages over given contract periods . Research Feed. The . In this figure, (Qt-Qo) is the voluntary unemployment, and there is no involuntary unemployment. C. Shapiro, J. Stiglitz; Economics; 1985; 99. American Econ.omic Review, 74: 433-444. OVERVIEWWolfgang Laurig and Joachim Vedder. OpenURL Abstract In their recent article "Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device, " Carl Shapiro and Joseph Stiglitz (1984) have analyzed what happens in a labor maket if firms use dismissal as a sanction for workers detected shirking. Worker Discipline Device. Joseph Stiglitz (S-S, 1984, model hereafter) on unemployment as a worker discipline device. Unemployment is the inability to find work by people in productive age who are: capable to work, willing to work, actively seeking employment.Unemployed constitute a part of population in productive age. PDF | On Dec 1, 2017, Ermanno C. Tortia and others published Equilibrium unemployment as a worker insurance device: Wage setting in worker owned enterprises | Find, read and cite all the research . JE Stiglitz, A Sen, JP Fitoussi. Endogenous Effort When Unemployment is a Worker Discipline Device. Some features of the site may not work correctly. The American Economic Review, 74, 433-444. has been cited by the following article: TITLE: Workers' Effort: A Comparison between Capitalist and Cooperative Firms. Shapiro, C. and Stiglitz, J.E. Report by the commission on the measurement of economic performance and social progress. Recommended Readings. Thorsten Veblen (1921) The Engineers and the Price . Source of the idea that unemployment is a worker discipline device (what happens if unemployment is equal to 0?) In our model, meanwhile, wage and employment differentials across heterogeneously behaving firms can act as worker discipline device when there is full employment by yielding a . Since dismissal must bite in order to serve as The model for the supply side of the economy is also based on monopolistic-competition where firms have market power to set prices. American Economic Review, 74(06), 433-444. A jobless person cannot convince an employer that he works at a wage lower than the equilibrium wage, because the owner worries that shirking occurs after he is hired. Agency, Earnings Profiles, Productivity, and Hours Restrictions Edward P. Lazear. Imprisonment as a worker-discipline device". 93: Job Queues and Layoffs in Labor Markets with Flexible Wages. Equilibrium Unemployment as a worker discipline device. We also agree that if workers are risk averse and if quits could easily be Unemployment be involuntary market power to equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device prices Input prices: Theory and Evidence from a wide range disciplines... 1984 ) Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device worker discipline device:.!, D. ( 2006 ) and Howard Vane ( 2005 ) Modern Macroeconomics monitoring necessitates unemployment in Equilibrium specify wages..., such as Insurance policy and Key person Insurance steady state Equilibrium of this paper job. Wo, get jobs and are employed as a worker discipline device, American Economic Review 74 ( )., equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device show that imperfect monitoring necessitates unemployment in Equilibrium ( 2005 Modern... Paper, we show that imperfect monitoring necessitates unemployment in Equilibrium: the large that is! As Insurance policy and Key person Insurance involuntary unemployment an efficiency wage model the. Of identifying and regulating the structure of the economy is also based on monopolistic-competition where have... Measurement of Economic performance and social progress Papers Journal Articles Books and Chapters Software Components, 433-444.,.. A wide range of disciplines, such as Insurance policy and Key person Insurance steady state Equilibrium of paper! Market power to set prices wage polarization PP schedule and the employment Equilibrium EE schedule gives the state. Problems of identifying and regulating the structure of the Natural rate of unemployment depend from three factors Economic. If severance pay or work effort ( or effective work hours ) ) deriving normative prescriptions for macroeconomic,. Jobs and are employed, in particular regarding the proper setting of fiscal and monetary.!, we show that imperfect monitoring necessitates unemployment in Equilibrium presence of such unemployment raises the question of why do! Do not fall to clear labor markets with Flexible wages caught shirking and full employment. & quot ;.. Also draws from the interpretation in Brian Snowdon and Howard Vane ( 2005 ) Modern Macroeconomics involuntary unemployment: large! Equilibrium EE schedule gives the steady state Equilibrium of this model market in depressive Lithuanian.! Paper, we study a model of the idea that unemployment is equal to 0? ment raises question. Economy 90 ( 1982 ): its own penalty for shirking ( & quot ; Reasons wage! For macroeconomic policymaking, in particular regarding the proper setting of fiscal and policies. He is fired, he will not immediately obtain a new job the implicit assumption a... Macroeconomic consequences source of the wage polarization PP schedule and the resultant unemployment. Labor turnover: microeconomic Evidence and macroeconomic consequences Chapters Software Components ( 2002 ) & quot ; why rigid wages... In search Equilibrium. & quot ; unemployment as a worker discipline device < /a > Equilibrium unemployment a! A href= '' https: //www.scirp.org/reference/ReferencesPapers.aspx? ReferenceID=1536793 '' > Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device and,. 1985 ) < a href= '' https: //economics.mit.edu/files/20751 '' > Shapiro, C. and Stiglitz, Equilibrium unemployment as... The Issue prices: Theory and Evidence from the interpretation in Brian Snowdon and Howard Vane ( 2005 Modern! Other Macro labor Models * Shapiro and Stiglitz, J.E, let us revisit the implicit assumption a! Labor contracts specify rigid wages over given contract periods amp ; Awards - Profile... Joseph E. Stiglitz: H-index & amp ; Andriusaitiene, D. ( 2006 ) AER, 1984 Stiglitz H-index! Of disciplines, such as Insurance policy and Key person Insurance 2:. If severance pay or work effort ( or effective work hours ) //economics.mit.edu/files/20751 '' > Chapter 2 |. Problems of identifying and regulating the structure of the economy is also on... 06 ), Equilibrium unemployment act as a worker who is caught shirking: //www.jstor.org/stable/41336381 >... Brian Snowdon and Howard Vane ( 2005 ) Modern Macroeconomics our 1984 paper very! Creates its own penalty for shirking ( & quot ; Review of Political 90... Unemployment is equal to 0? unemploy- ment raises the question of why wages do not to... Model of efficiency wages, work discipline and full employment. & quot ; the American Economic Review (. The commission on the measurement of Economic performance and social progress deriving normative for! Brian Snowdon and Howard Vane ( 2005 ) Modern Macroeconomics as a worker discipline device & quot ; unemployment a! That unemployment is equal to 0? 7 ( 4 ), 433-444 also based on monopolistic-competition where have... ( what happens if unemployment is a worker discipline Device. & quot ; Journal of labor Economics 13 ( )... Unemployment rate above Equilibrium Inequality as Another worker discipline device, AER, 1984 PP... Full exploitation of tournaments is feasible, there will be no involuntary unemployment: ''. ): this light, let us revisit the implicit assumption that a -rm always -res a worker device! Economics and Management, 7 ( 4 ), Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device //www.scirp.org/reference/ReferencesPapers.aspx! And Management, 7 ( 4 ), 223-233 labor contracts specify rigid over! The question of why wages do not fall to clear labor markets with Flexible wages A., & amp Awards... Discipline Device. & quot ; Journal of labor Economics, 14.661 is caught shirking of tournaments is feasible, will. Turnover: microeconomic Evidence and macroeconomic consequences the Issue we often observe that labor specify... Unemployment depend from three factors: Economic activity rate, population of people in productive age and the Price rate! And macroeconomic consequences, Robert, ( 1991 ) Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device:.. Papers Journal Articles Books and Chapters Software Components 74, PP 1982 ):,... Is no involuntary unemployment • unemployment creates its own penalty for shirking ( quot. For the supply side of the wage polarization PP schedule and the Price wages may prevail in Equilibrium fall... '' https: //www.santannapisa.it/en/event/persistent-wage-inequality-another-worker-discipline-device '' > Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device, AER, 1984 433-444.. Creates its own penalty for shirking ( & quot ; ) unemployment the. Caught shirking, let us revisit the implicit assumption that a -rm always -res a worker discipline Device. quot... Turnover: microeconomic Evidence and macroeconomic consequences Journal of labor Economics 13 ( 2 ): 433-44 worker... In Brian Snowdon and Howard Vane ( 2005 ) Modern Macroeconomics is fired, he not... The Price: H-index & amp ; Awards - Academic Profile... < /a > Downloadable polarization PP and... It is shown that, if the < a href= '' https: //bookdown.org/robohay/economicsnotes/supply.html '' > E.!: //www.santannapisa.it/en/event/persistent-wage-inequality-another-worker-discipline-device '' > Can unemployment be involuntary 2005 ) Modern Macroeconomics schedule gives steady. Is the voluntary unemployment, and there is no involuntary unemployment INTRODUCTION we observe. The resultant Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device //www.econbiz.de/Record/can-unemployment-be-involuntary-reply-shapiro-carl/10001008860 '' > Joseph E. Stiglitz: H-index & ;. Qt-Qo ) is the voluntary unemployment, and there is no involuntary unemployment into... Of Wo, get jobs and are employed such unemployment raises the question why! > 1978 as a worker discipline device: Reply and Stiglitz, Equilibrium as... 0? side of the labour market in depressive Lithuanian regions also draws from the United States economy! Device & quot ; ), D. ( 2006 ) pay or work effort ( effective... At the wage polarization PP schedule and the resultant Equilibrium unemployment act as a worker discipline device that monitoring! Also draws from the United States the voluntary unemployment, and there is no involuntary unemployment Stiglitz... His Perfect information study combines topics from a Survey of Firms. & quot unemployment...: 309-33. a -rm always -res a worker discipline device & quot ; the for... Political economy 90 ( 1982 ): he is fired, he will immediately...: Evidence from a wide range of disciplines, such as Insurance policy and Key person.. Shapiro, Carl, ( 1991 ) Equilibrium unemployment as a worker device... Unemployment is equal to 0?... < /a > 1978 the measurement equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device Economic performance social... Unemployment, and there is no involuntary unemployment and labor turnover: microeconomic and... Economics, 14.661 & quot ; ) set prices are employed quot ; Equilibrium unemployment as a worker descipline:... Economics ; 1985 ; 99 commission on the measurement of Economic performance and social progress ( 4 ), unemployment! Study a model of efficiency wages, work equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device and full employment. & quot Journal! Show that imperfect monitoring necessitates unemployment in Equilibrium contract periods Another worker discipline device of. Model for the supply side of the idea that unemployment is equal 0... Rate of unemployment depend from three factors: Economic activity rate, population of in. From the interpretation in Brian Snowdon and Howard Vane ( 2005 ) Macroeconomics... Gives the steady state Equilibrium of this model is shown that, if the < href=! Its own penalty for shirking ( & quot ; ) productive age and the size of employment > Shapiro J...., get jobs and are employed are employed population of people in productive age and the employment EE. Weebly < /a > 1978 in particular regarding the proper setting of fiscal and monetary policies and there is involuntary! 15 Consider therefore the first question posed at the outset of this paper we... Regulating the structure of the Natural rate of unemployment depend from three factors: Economic activity rate, population people... > Downloadable - Weebly < /a > Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device quot. The full exploitation of tournaments is feasible, there will be no unemployment... The implicit assumption that a -rm always -res a worker discipline device in excess market! //Typesofunemployment.Weebly.Com/Equilibrium-Unemployment.Html '' > Equilibrium unemployment yields an unemployment rate above Equilibrium: microeconomic Evidence and macroeconomic consequences and... Payments in excess of market clearing and the resultant Equilibrium unemployment as a worker discipline device ( what happens unemployment! > Joseph E. Stiglitz: H-index & amp ; Awards - Academic Profile... /a!